Choosing an agency ยท Timing

Should I hire a YouTube agency before my offer is proven?

Usually not. Prove the offer first, then let YouTube scale it.

Menno Kater Menno Kater · · 5 min read

Usually not. Hire a YouTube agency once your offer sells, by hand or through referrals, because a channel amplifies an offer that works and does not fix one that does not. Our own rules: the audit needs a channel with videos, even if it is only ten; the growth partnership needs an offer that already sells and read access to the numbers; the retainer is for founders and experts who sell something above a few hundred euros.

Want to know what this means for your business? Book a 30-minute call → Or start with the free channel check.

Should you hire a YouTube agency before your offer is proven?

In most cases, no. A YouTube channel brings the right people to an offer. If the offer does not convert yet, more of the right people will not fix that, and you pay a monthly fee to find out. Sell it first: by hand, through your network, in a few calls. Once people buy and stay, a channel has something to send them to.

There is one exception: you already sell, just only to people who know you. That is not an unproven offer. That is an offer with a distribution problem, and that is exactly what a channel solves.

Our fit rules, offer by offer

We publish who each offer is for. These are the rules we apply ourselves, as they stand on our site:

OfferFits whenDoes not fit when
Audit and optimisation, 950 euroYou sell something above a few hundred euros, your channel already has videos, even if it is only ten, and you want clients, not viewsThere is no channel yet; then there is nothing to audit
Done-for-you retainer, from 3,500 euro a monthYou are a founder or expert with a high-ticket offer and want it done for you, about a shoot day a month on cameraYou do not want to be on camera, or the offer changes every month
Growth partnership, partly paid from growthThe offer already sells with paying members or clients who stay, you want to be the face, and you share read access to Stripe or whatever you charge throughNo numbers to share; then there is no split to agree on

Details per offer are on the pricing page and the growth partnership page.

How to tell if your offer is proven

  • People have paid for it, more than once, and not only friends.
  • Clients or members stay, or come back.
  • You can say in one sentence who buys it and why.
  • You know roughly what one new client is worth to you.

If you can tick those, a channel has something to amplify. If you cannot, the most useful content you can make right now is the sales conversation itself.

What to do first if the offer is not proven

  1. Sell the offer by hand to five people. Write down every question they ask before they say yes.
  2. Those questions are your first video topics. Film a few yourself, simply, to see how it feels on camera.
  3. Once people buy and stay, get the decisions made once: the audit fixes your channel and your twenty best videos and includes the Channel Plan for what to make next.
  4. When the channel needs a weekly rhythm you cannot hold yourself, that is the moment for a done-for-you team.

What a proven offer plus YouTube can do

The case we point to started with an offer that already sold. Two e-commerce founders, Arthur & Bryan, had a paid community with about 50 members. With YouTube they went from $12.5K to $140K per month, to more than 400 members at $249, almost entirely organic. More than 90% of new members came through YouTube. The channel did not invent the offer. It brought the people.

If that sounds like where you are, see how we work with founders, from the first call to the first video live.

When hiring early does make sense

  • You sell well in person but have no time to make content; the offer is proven, the distribution is not.
  • You have a proven offer in one market and want to bring it to a new one.
  • You are a known expert in your field and the offer is a direct extension of work clients already pay you for.
Should I hire a YouTube agency before my offer is proven?
Usually not. A channel amplifies an offer that works; it does not fix one that does not. Sell it first, by hand or through referrals. If it already sells but only to people who know you, that is a distribution problem, and a channel solves exactly that.
How many videos do I need before a YouTube channel audit makes sense?
At Menno Kater, the audit needs a channel that already has videos, even if it is only ten. With no channel yet there is nothing to audit; start with a free call instead.
What does a growth partnership require?
An offer that already sells, with paying members or clients who stay; you as the face, about a shoot day a month; and read access to Stripe or whatever you charge through. No numbers, no split.
What should I do before hiring a YouTube agency?
Sell the offer by hand to a few people and note every question they ask before buying. Those questions become your first videos. Once the offer sells and clients stay, a team or an audit makes sense.

Not sure your offer is ready?

Book a free 30-minute call, in your time zone. We look at your offer and your channel and tell you straight whether now is the moment.

Let's talk →

Already have a channel? Start with the free channel check, Menno looks at it himself before you talk.

Free channel check by Menno →