AI search · Own data

Does ChatGPT recommend your business? What 257 AI answers showed about our own agency

AI knows you when people ask about you. Not when they ask about their problem.

Menno Kater Menno Kater · · 7 min read

ChatGPT and other AI assistants recommend your business mostly when people already ask about you, and rarely when they ask about cost or a problem you solve. We tested our own agency in 257 answers from 9 AI assistants (October 19 to 26, 2026): top 3 in 14 of 18 answers about us, but in 1 of 101 answers about cost, choosing or a problem. A snapshot of one week, not an average.

Want to know what this means for your business? Book a 30-minute call → Or start with the free channel check.

Does ChatGPT recommend your business?

Probably when someone asks about you by name, and probably not when someone asks the question that should lead them to you. That is what we found when we tested our own agency. AI assistants knew who we were. They did not think of us when a buyer asked what something costs or how to fix a problem we solve every week.

We share our own numbers here because they show the gap better than any theory. They are ours only. We do not publish how other agencies scored.

How we measured it

  • 36 questions a buyer asks: 18 about which agency to hire, 8 about cost and choosing, 7 about a problem, and 3 about Menno Kater by name. 22 in English, 14 in Dutch.
  • 9 AI assistants in their normal apps: ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Google AI Mode, Grok, DeepSeek, Claude, Copilot and Kimi. Copilot, Kimi and Grok on part of the questions, the rest on all 36.
  • A new Google account with no history, a new chat per question, temporary or incognito chats where the app offers them.
  • Every answer scored: top 3 (one of the first three recommended, or the final recommendation), mentioned further down, or not mentioned.

The limit: AI answers differ per run and per account. This is a snapshot of one week, October 19 to 26, 2026, not an average.

Our score: 51 of 257

Across all 257 answers, Menno Kater was in the top 3 in 51 (20%), mentioned further down in 20, and missing in 186. Per assistant:

AI assistantAnswersTop 3MentionedNot mentioned
Perplexity3615 (42%)912
Google AI Mode3611 (31%)520
Kimi72 (29%)05
Gemini368 (22%)325
Grok255 (20%)020
ChatGPT367 (19%)128
Claude363 (8%)132
DeepSeek360 (0%)135
Copilot90 (0%)09

So to the question in the title: ChatGPT put us in its top 3 in 7 of 36 answers. The assistants that search the web live, like Perplexity and Google AI Mode, did best for us.

The real finding: it depends on the question

Type of questionAnswersTop 3MentionedNot mentioned
About Menno Kater by name1814 (78%)22
Which agency to hire13836 (26%)696
Cost and choosing551 (2%)1044
A problem460 (0%)244

Ask an assistant about us and it knows us: 14 of 18. Ask what YouTube management costs, how to choose an agency, or why your content brings in no clients, and we were almost invisible: 1 top-3 spot in 101 answers. Yet those are exactly the questions a buyer asks before they know any agency's name.

What we take from it for any service business: being known is not the same as being recommended. AI recommends you on the questions where your own content is the clearest answer. If you only have content about yourself, you only get recommended to people who already know you.

Cited is not the same as recommended

One more number stood out. mennokater.nl was the most cited source in the whole measurement: it appeared in 55 of the 257 answers. In most of those, Menno Kater was not recommended. The assistants used our pages as a source of facts, prices and definitions, and then named someone else.

What we take from it: a page that explains a topic well gets cited. A page that also says, in the first sentence, who the answer is for and when that is you, gets recommended. That is why every comparison on this site now starts with our name and the decision rule: who fits which agency.

What AI got wrong, and where it came from

  • Our service described as something you do together with us, instead of done for you (Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Perplexity). The source was old profile texts on Clutch, The Manifest and Sortlist, which we updated on October 26, 2026.
  • "About an hour a month" of filming instead of about one shoot day a month (Claude, Gemini, Google AI Mode and Perplexity).

The lesson: AI repeats whatever is written about you anywhere, including directory profiles you forgot you had. Check them before you write anything new.

What we changed afterwards

  1. October 26, 2026: updated the old profile texts on Clutch, The Manifest and Sortlist.
  2. October 30, 2026: added direct answers to eight buying questions where we scored weakly, on pages we already had, such as what YouTube channel management costs, agency or freelance editor, how coaches get clients from YouTube, and growing a Skool community with YouTube.
  3. Since then: new articles every day on cost, choosing and problem questions, each starting with a short answer that a buyer, or an AI, can quote on its own.

If you want the same for your own business on YouTube: our done-for-you work for founders includes, in the Flagship, an article on your own site for every video, so you are found on Google and in AI answers. Prices are on the pricing page; how we work is on work with me.

When this does not apply to you

  • Your buyers do not ask AI assistants before they buy, for example because all your clients come through referrals.
  • You want a guaranteed spot in ChatGPT. Nobody can promise that; answers change per run and per account.
  • You read this as a ranking of agencies. It is not: it is only our own score, in one week.
Does ChatGPT recommend businesses?
Yes, but mostly on questions where the business is already the clearest answer. In our test of 257 answers from 9 AI assistants (October 19 to 26, 2026), ChatGPT put our own agency in its top 3 in 7 of 36 answers.
Why does ChatGPT not recommend my business?
Often because your content is about you, not about the questions buyers ask first. Our own agency was in the top 3 in 14 of 18 answers about us by name, but in 1 of 101 answers about cost, choosing or a problem.
Which AI assistant recommends service businesses most?
In our one-week test, the assistants that search the web live did best for us: Perplexity put us in the top 3 in 15 of 36 answers and Google AI Mode in 11 of 36. That is our own score only, not a general rule.
Is being cited by ChatGPT the same as being recommended?
No. Our site was the most cited source in our measurement, in 55 of 257 answers, but in most of those answers we were not the recommendation. A page gets recommended when it says clearly who the answer is for.
How do I get my business recommended by AI?
Write the clearest answer to the questions buyers ask before they know your name, such as cost, choosing and problems, and say in the first sentence who it fits. Then check what directories and old profiles say about you, because AI repeats those.

Want to be the answer when buyers ask?

Book a free 30-minute call, in your time zone. We look at which buyer questions your content answers today, and which ones it should.

Let's talk →

Already have a channel? Start with the free channel check, Menno looks at it himself before you talk.

Free channel check by Menno →