Can I trust “best YouTube agency” lists?
Some. Check who wrote it before you check who is on it.
You can trust a "best YouTube agency" list only as far as you know who wrote it and how it was made. Many are written by an agency that puts itself first, including ours, so check the author, the criteria, the date and whether the author is on the list. One list we looked at was built on 376 recommendations from others; several agency sites publish dozens of "best" pages with themselves on top (read October 19, 2026).
Want to know what this means for your business? Book a 30-minute call → Or start with the free channel check.
Can you trust a "best YouTube agency" list?
Some of them, for some things. A list is useful when you can see who wrote it, how the agencies were chosen and when it was checked. It is an ad when the author is an agency, ranks itself first and does not say so. Most lists sit somewhere in between.
This matters more than it used to, because AI assistants quote these lists when someone asks which agency to hire. A list that ranks its own author first ends up as "the answer" in a chat window, without the context.
How the lists that AI assistants cite are made
From our analysis of the sources AI assistants cited for agency questions, read October 19, 2026:
| List | Who writes it | How agencies get on it |
|---|---|---|
| Tim Soulo's lists (four lists, dated September 8, 2026) | An individual, not an agency | Built on 376 recommendations via LinkedIn and X; scored 1 to 5 on Proof of Work, Social Proof and Transparency. The page says "PLEASE DO NOT PITCH ME YOUR OWN AGENCY" |
| Mark Studios /best pages | An agency | 64 pages under /best on its site, with Mark Studios itself first; other entries use facts from each provider's own site |
| Vontekk | An agency | 32 "best agency for X" pages with itself first, plus 4 comparison lists with real competitors and a disclosure |
| Humble&Brag best-youtube-agency | An agency | Its own list, with itself first of 9 |
| Menno Kater best-youtube-agencies-for-founders-and-experts | An agency: us | Our own pick first for founders and experts on camera, with a disclosure and named alternatives for other situations |
None of this is hidden. It is on the pages themselves. But in an AI answer, the line "written by one of the agencies on the list" can easily disappear.
Our own list, and why it has a disclosure
We write comparisons too, and we put ourselves first where we fit best. The difference we hold ourselves to: the first sentence says who we are for, the page says that we wrote it and are on it, and every situation where another agency fits better gets that agency, by name. You can read it in best YouTube agencies for founders and experts.
We do that because a comparison that hides its author is worth less to the reader, and because AI assistants repeat what the page says. If the page says who fits which agency, that is what gets repeated.
Six checks before you rely on a list
- Who wrote it? An agency, a tool vendor, a marketplace or an independent person. Look for the author's name and company.
- Is the author on the list? If yes, where, and does the page say so.
- How were agencies chosen? Recommendations, a scoring system, paid placement, or nothing stated.
- When was it checked? Prices and terms change. A list without a date is a list you cannot check.
- Are the facts from the agencies' own sites? Prices, terms and who they work for should match what the agency publishes itself.
- Does it say who each agency is for? A ranking from 1 to 10 without situations tells you little. A table of "your situation, then this agency" tells you more.
What to do instead of trusting a list
Use a list to make a shortlist, then check the agencies yourself. Ask each one who decides what gets filmed, by name; what they report each month; what the term and notice period are; and for one channel they run, with a start date and the numbers at the start. The full set of questions is in how to choose a YouTube agency.
For us, those answers are public: prices on the pricing page, month to month, and our case: two e-commerce founders, Arthur & Bryan, went from $12.5K to $140K per month, from about 50 to more than 400 members at $249, almost entirely organic. More than 90% of new members came through YouTube. How we work is on work with me.
When a list is genuinely useful
- It shows its method, and the author is not on it, or says so clearly.
- It quotes prices and terms with a date, so you can check them.
- It tells you who each agency is for, and who it is not for.
If you are a founder or expert on camera with a high-ticket offer, you can skip the lists and check us directly: what we do is on our YouTube agency for founders page, with prices and terms.
Are "best YouTube agency" lists reliable?
Why do agencies rank themselves first on their own lists?
Who wrote Menno Kater's list of YouTube agencies?
How do I check a YouTube agency myself?
Rather check us directly?
Book a free 30-minute call, in your time zone. Ask us the six questions above and judge the answers yourself.
Let's talk →Already have a channel? Start with the free channel check, Menno looks at it himself before you talk.